Exploring the Different Types of Nuclear Fusion

by | Jun 12, 2024

Nuclear Fusion

The quest for achieving practical nuclear fusion has driven the exploration of various types of fusion, each offering a distinct methodology and holding its own promise for future energy production.

At its core, nuclear fusion involves the merging of two light atomic nuclei into a heavier nucleus, releasing an enormous amount of energy. This process contrasts with nuclear fission, where heavy atomic nuclei split into lighter ones. Fusion promises a virtually limitless supply of energy with minimal environmental impact, making it a key player in the future of energy production.

Magnetic Confinement Fusion (MCF)

Fusion JET

Tokamak Reactors: The best known type, using powerful magnetic fields to contain hot plasma in a chamber.

Stellarators or Helical Reactor: Similar to tokamaks but with a twisted magnetic field configuration, potentially offering better stability.

These reactors hold immense promise as a future clean energy source. Here’s a breakdown of how it works:

Fuel and Heating

MCF uses a fuel of isotopes of hydrogen – deuterium and tritium. These are heated to extremely high temperatures, much hotter than the sun’s core, to form a hot, charged gas called plasma.

Magnetic Confinement

This superheated plasma can’t be contained by any traditional material because of its high temperature, (over 100 million Celcious). Instead, MCF uses powerful magnetic fields to confine the plasma. Imagine a giant, invisible donut – that’s the typical basic shape the magnetic field creates. The doughnut-shaped field is called a torus. The strong magnetic forces accelerate the charged particles in the plasma around the tooidal shaped field, preventing the plasma from touching the walls of the reactor, which would quench the plasma and stop the fusion reaction.

Fusion Reaction

Within the confined plasma, the nuclei of the deuterium and tritium atoms fuse together, releasing a tremendous amount of energy in the form of heat. This is the same process that powers the sun and other stars.

If successful, MCF has the potential to provide a clean, safe, and virtually limitless source of energy for the future. The principle of achieving fusion by MCF has been proven with several large scale, short term experiments and the current challenge is to design and build a commercially viable fusion facility with an acceptable system life time.

Inertial Confinement Fusion (ICF)

Inertial Confinement Fusion (ICF) is another approach to achieving fusion on Earth, but instead of using magnetic fields, this type of nuclear fusion relies on extreme pressure and heat to create the necessary conditions. Here’s a simplified breakdown:

Fuel and Target

Similar to MCF, ICF uses hydrogen isotopes (deuterium and tritium) as fuel. These are packed into a tiny capsule.

High-Powered Lasers (or Ion Beams)

Powerful lasers (or sometimes ion beams) are fired at the capsule from all directions.

Compression and Ignition

The intense laser blasts rapidly compress and heat the fuel capsule, creating an incredibly hot and dense environment. This triggers fusion reactions within the fuel, releasing energy. Imagine squeezing a tiny balloon filled with fuel so hard and fast that it ignites.

The Race Against Time

Because the fuel isn’t confined by a magnetic field, the entire process needs to happen very quickly, in billionths of a second. It’s a race against time to achieve fusion before the compressed fuel cools and falls apart.

ICF is a promising avenue for fusion energy. Researchers are actively working on improving laser technology and designing more efficient ways to capture the released energy.

Magnetized Target Fusion (MTF)

Magnetized Target Fusion (MTF)
Magnetized Target Fusion (MTF), also referred to as magneto-inertial fusion, is a more recent type of nuclear fusion that tries to bridge the gap between the two main approaches: Magnetic Confinement Fusion (MCF) and Inertial Confinement Fusion (ICF). Unlike MCF which relies on expensive superconducting magnets, MTF uses simpler and cheaper electromagnets for the initial confinement. MTF hopes to achieve higher fuel densities compared to standard MCF, potentially leading to more efficient fusion reactions. Here’s how it works:

Combines Concepts

MTF borrows elements from both MCF and ICF. It utilizes magnetic fields for some plasma confinement, like MCF, but also relies on rapid compression for ignition, similar to ICF.

Fuel and Target

Similar to MCF, MTF starts with a preheated and magnetized plasma, often within a chamber. As with ICF, MTF uses hydrogen isotopes (deuterium-tritium) encased in a target which is usually in liquid form and injected into the chamber.

Magnetic Field and Compression

The target is placed within a chamber with an electromagnetic field. This magnetic field confines the plasma to a certain extent, but not as strongly as in MCF. Then, powerful drivers, like pistons or jets of liquid metal, rapidly compress the target.

Fusion Ignition

Fusion reactions release a burst of energy, which can be used to heat a surrounding material and eventually generate electricity

The rapid compression during the target squeeze can introduce instabilities in the plasma, potentially disrupting the fusion process. Since MTF operates in pulses, efficiently repeating the fuel injection, compression, and energy extraction cycle is crucial for a viable power source. More research is needed to optimize the compression process and achieve sustained fusion reactions.

Cold Fusion

Cold fusion is a hypothetical process where atomic nuclei fuse at or near room temperature, in contrast to the incredibly high temperatures (millions of degrees) required for traditional fusion reactions (“hot fusion”). It has been a controversial topic since 1989 when reports of successful cold fusion experiments surfaced. However, there is no conclusive evidence to support its existence.

Advanced Fusion Concepts

Advanced fusion concepts refer to approaches beyond the main types of nuclear fusion mentioned earlier. Two intriguing advanced fusion concepts are Aneutronic Fusion and Fusion-Fission Hybrids.

Aneutronic Fusion

Aneutronic Fusion is a type of nuclear fusion where the goal is to minimize the production of neutrons. Unlike standard fusion reactions, which release a significant amount of their energy as neutrons, aneutronic fusion aims to capture energy from charged particles instead. This approach is more efficient reducing radioactive waste, simplify the reactor design and create electrical energy directly. The challenges include achieving the higher temperature required for this method and this technique will release less energy compared to the D-T reaction.

Fusion-Fission Hybrids

Fusion-Fission Hybrids combines aspects of both fusion and fission reactors into a single system. Fusion reactors can provide a source of neutrons, which can be used to “burn” fissile material in a subcritical fission reactor.

Overall, Aneutronic Fusion and Fusion-Fission Hybrids are innovative approaches that aim to address some of the challenges associated with traditional fusion reactors. However, both concepts are in the early stages of development and require significant research and engineering advancements before they become a reality.

Precision Ceramics and Fusion

Precision Ceramics has provided technical ceramic components for many fusion environments over the course of three decades. For more information on the ceramics used in fusion, please visit our fusion page. The extreme environments in the multiple fusion systems being developed mean that engineering ceramics will be required across the fusion core systems and the peripherals. Even higher performing materials will need to be developed to survive the most challenging applications.

If you have any questions regarding which ceramic material might be best for your application, please don’t hesitate to contact us.

Related Topics

Fusion JET

Ceramics for Fusion

At Precision Ceramics, our expertise in working with ceramics for Fusion reactors spans many decades, specializing in supplying a wide range of ceramics for use in fusion environments.

Ceramic Materials

Materials

Precision Ceramics offers a wide range of advanced ceramic materials. We can help with the engineering tolerances, design for manufacture, selection of the materials and application environment questions.

Geoff Randle

Andy Duncan (Author)

Andy Duncan, Business Development Director has spent over 30 years in Engineering Ceramics within Technical Management and Business Development roles. Andy’s ceramics application experience is broad, spanning design and selection of ceramic materials including alumina’s, zirconia’s, nitrides, carbides, silicate ceramics, ceramic to metal joining, piezoceramics. Combined with diverse application and design knowledge with experience in a variety markets, Andy can help guide you towards the best suited material to fit your application.

Most Recent Posts

Wear Resistant Ceramics: Sliding, Abrasion & Impact

Wear Resistant Ceramics: Sliding, Abrasion & Impact

How do ceramic materials perform against sliding, abrasive or impact wear?Ceramics are inherently very wear resistant due to their extreme hardness; these materials have values close to the hardest known material, diamond. They have also the capability to be machined...

Ceramic Manufacturing Process: Quantity, Design and Cost

Ceramic Manufacturing Process: Quantity, Design and Cost

How does quantity influence tooling costs and the ceramic manufacturing process?Quantity can be a game-changer in the ceramic manufacturing process. When you're making large quantities of ceramics, prices tend to drop, as with any other product. And that's when it...

Advanced Ceramics Design and Manufacturing: Key Considerations

Advanced Ceramics Design and Manufacturing: Key Considerations

What design and material considerations are there from an application and advanced ceramics manufacturing perspective?Whether you're manufacturing advanced ceramics, or any other material, defining what you need for the application is the crucial first step. You are...